Penalty or free kick with yellow/red card

SS FC · Post by **SS FC** » Wed Jun 11, 2008 9:06 pm

I'm afraid it's not possible to put it in the game, but I try to ask you for your opinion.
Should there be a yellow or red card before a free or penalty kick, like it is in real? I think it would get the game closer to reality, but is it possible to apply?

sljivovica · Post by **sljivovica** » Wed Jun 11, 2008 9:23 pm

Good point

cruxify · Post by **cruxify** » Tue Jun 17, 2008 3:36 pm

Yes, not always of course but I'm surprise it's not included. If anything the game text should read something along the lines of, "Player A was pulled down in the box by Player B. The referee has pointed to the spot and awarded the penalty". Then the next line of text will read the outcome. Similarly with freekicks, "Player A comes in late on Player B and a freekick is awarded just outside the box".

atleti scouse · Post by **atleti scouse** » Tue Jul 08, 2008 6:01 pm

I agree with Crux.

ADITYA · Post by **ADITYA** » Sat Jul 19, 2008 5:17 pm

hey even in real matches fouls also give free k's and p.k's it is not neccesasy that card is must.

YouKnowWho · Post by **YouKnowWho** » Fri Jul 25, 2008 8:13 pm

cruxify wrote:Yes, not always of course but I'm surprise it's not included. If anything the game text should read something along the lines of, "Player A was pulled down in the box by Player B. The referee has pointed to the spot and awarded the penalty". Then the next line of text will read the outcome. Similarly with freekicks, "Player A comes in late on Player B and a freekick is awarded just outside the box".

Crux have you ever saw a "The referee pointed to the spot" or Player a pull player B IN BOX" or "Referee awarded penalty" in your match report. I never saw them. All we had is "Player A shoot to left/right/middle corner from penalty spot." So if we really want to make it more realistic we need to include more messages for penalty.

cruxify · Post by **cruxify** » Sat Jul 26, 2008 4:39 am

YouKnowWho wrote:
cruxify wrote:Yes, not always of course but I'm surprise it's not included. If anything the game text should read something along the lines of, "Player A was pulled down in the box by Player B. The referee has pointed to the spot and awarded the penalty". Then the next line of text will read the outcome. Similarly with freekicks, "Player A comes in late on Player B and a freekick is awarded just outside the box".
Crux have you ever saw a "The referee pointed to the spot" or Player a pull player B IN BOX" or "Referee awarded penalty" in your match report. I never saw them. All we had is "Player A shoot to left/right/middle corner from penalty spot." So if we really want to make it more realistic we need to include more messages for penalty.

No that's why I said it should be added...