SoccerProject

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 11:30 am**

Loaning players.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 11:49 am**

That concept is too dangerous for cheating at the moment.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 1:57 pm**

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 3:59 pm**

Jumbo wrote:why

Imagine the following situation:
It's the last 3 games of a season. Team A has secured their position in a division and can't relegate or promote anymore. The manager of Team A is a friend of the one from Team B. Team B is going for promotion, but plays against an opponent that has built a stronger team, Team C. Team B loans some strong players from Team A and gets the promotion because its team is now stronger than Team C.
It causes a big disadvantage to Team C, which didn't have 'friends' on sp to loan such players from.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 4:06 pm**

But that doesn't happen in real life either. You cannot loan a player for less than a season. So if you want to loan a player, you can only get him at the begining of a new season and for at least 1 complete season.

The cheating issue I see coming up here is, if the team, which is loaning a player, has the possibility to buy him afterwards. Then cheating would be possible.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 4:10 pm**

tuways wrote:But that doesn't happen in real life either. You cannot loan a player for less than a season. So if you want to loan a player, you can only get him at the begining of a new season and for at least 1 complete season.

Even then it's the same problem right?
A team gets an advantage because it can loan players without too much trouble from another team, while the competitive teams might not have that advantage.
A team won't let good players go that easily, unless they go to a friend.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 5:07 pm**

It's possible to create a system where you can only loan one player from a team. In DO all teams can loan out 2 players and loan in 2 players. This system works. It's also possible to create a system that makes it impossible to list your 11 best players for loan.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 5:10 pm**

matt wrote:
Jumbo wrote:why
Imagine the following situation:
It's the last 3 games of a season. Team A has secured their position in a division and can't relegate or promote anymore. The manager of Team A is a friend of the one from Team B. Team B is going for promotion, but plays against an opponent that has built a stronger team, Team C. Team B loans some strong players from Team A and gets the promotion because its team is now stronger than Team C.
It causes a big disadvantage to Team C, which didn't have 'friends' on sp to loan such players from.

But thats not cheating..

Thats the life

, real life

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 7:09 pm**

Nasko wrote:
matt wrote:
Jumbo wrote:why
Imagine the following situation:
It's the last 3 games of a season. Team A has secured their position in a division and can't relegate or promote anymore. The manager of Team A is a friend of the one from Team B. Team B is going for promotion, but plays against an opponent that has built a stronger team, Team C. Team B loans some strong players from Team A and gets the promotion because its team is now stronger than Team C.
It causes a big disadvantage to Team C, which didn't have 'friends' on sp to loan such players from.
But thats not cheating.. Thats the life , real life

and this is a game...an online game.

Posted: **Sat Jan 27, 2007 11:20 pm**

Yeah, but Sjarel and everyone is there to make the game more realistic all the time...

If you do not care about realism, quit and go try playing SundayLeague! I paid money for it to realise it is complete shit.

And hence, everybody is here trying to make SoccerProject better, and not "Shitter"...

Posted: **Sun Jan 28, 2007 12:02 am**

Nasko wrote:
matt wrote:
Jumbo wrote:why
Imagine the following situation:
It's the last 3 games of a season. Team A has secured their position in a division and can't relegate or promote anymore. The manager of Team A is a friend of the one from Team B. Team B is going for promotion, but plays against an opponent that has built a stronger team, Team C. Team B loans some strong players from Team A and gets the promotion because its team is now stronger than Team C.
It causes a big disadvantage to Team C, which didn't have 'friends' on sp to loan such players from.
But thats not cheating.. Thats the life , real life

Can you also tell where in the reality did you see this kind of activity?
I mean soccer reality.

I agree that the game has to be more and more realistic but this is not realistic.

Posted: **Sun Jan 28, 2007 12:39 am**

In life there is enough cheating too. I can follow Nasko on that.
But like unicool said, this is a game and we'd like to keep it fair enough for all players.

Posted: **Sun Jan 28, 2007 9:59 pm**

Loan Players is GOOD thing

Posted: **Sun Jan 28, 2007 9:59 pm**

Yeah great idea

Posted: **Sun Jan 28, 2007 10:06 pm**

YES It is a great idea